Soft Targets, Hard Lessons - Why terrorists value your school as a target and what you can do!
Unfortunately, the recent trend on the part of some law enforcement and many security consultants has been to minimize the likelihood that a school(s) in the US may be subject to attack by terrorists. In fact, those who attempt to keep the idea of a potential terror attack at school alive in the minds of school administrators and security personnel have been criticized as trying to “hype” the threat to increase their own value. The fact of the matter is that the thought of our children being targeted in a place where they should be most safe is so frightening that is has been rendered unmentionable, if not unthinkable. Some even speculate that terrorists fear that an attack on a U.S. school(s) would cause a reverse affect. That is to say, that the fear and panic created by such an attack would motivate the American people (rather than de-motivate) to exterminate radical Islamic extremists throughout the world.
Yet, we have no evidence that the terrorist fears that the killing of children would have any affect beyond their stated goal(s). In fact there is evidence to the contrary. Video tapes have been found in Afghanistan showing al-Qaeda terrorists training to take over schools. Subsequently, al-Qaeda spokesman Suleiman Abu Gheith declared al-Qaeda's "right" to kill 2 million American children in retaliation for Muslim civilian deaths in the war on terror. Recently, CNN reported that local law enforcement agencies received a “routine” FBI and Homeland Security Department advisory relating to “Foreigners under recent investigation include ‘some with ties to extremist groups’ who have been able to purchase (school) buses and acquire licenses.”
But the greatest evidence to date is the horrific Belsan school massacre in Russia during which 700 people were wounded and 338 killed, including 172 students. This terrorist attack was perpetrated by Muslim extremists with definite historical links to al-Qaeda. Whether al-Qaeda assisted in the planning of this particular attack is under investigation. It was noted that several Arabs were among the terrorists killed by Russian Special Forces during the massacre.
The recommendations contained in this checklist are not intended to represent or to replace a comprehensive school security program. Such a program would include much more. Many of the procedures included in the checklist are routine in districts with full-time security operations. Whether your school district has full-time security coverage, or has minimal security resources, these recommendations may be used as a focal point around which to build an appropriately renewed sense of awareness. The recommendations have been constructed in several “modules” each of which depicts the basic recommendation, the audit point or “question” to be addressed for each recommendation and the departments that would potentially be involved in the addressing the recommendation.
- Does your screening process include volunteers, cafeteria workers, mechanics, bus drivers, and security, in addition to educational staff?
- Does your procedure allow for actual courthouse searches, rather than database searches, which are typically not accurate?
- Do your searchers do Social Security Number traces to identify any out-of-state venues that should be checked?
- Do your outside contractors use due-diligence screening procedures to check the backgrounds of their workers who regularly visit your school?
- Human Resources
Module 2: Review the physical security of bus yards and garages; review transportation security in general.
- Are vehicle garages alarmed, and are the alarms in working order?
- Are fenced-in areas gated, locked, and adequately illuminated at night?
- Do drivers do “pilot inspections” of their vehicles before placing them into service each day? Is this done again after each time the vehicle has been left unattended?
- Are bus drivers equipped with two-way radios or cell phones?
- Are drivers trained to be aware of and to report suspicious vehicles that appear to be following their busses during their routes?
- Do drivers keep a student roster for each bus route, to include student name, address, primary and secondary emergency contact numbers, and medical authorization information?
- Contract or proprietary bus operators
- Health Services
Module 3: a) Review the adequacy of physical security in and around campus buildings; b) Review placement of security cameras and review monitoring practices
- Review the adequacy of physical security in and around campus buildings
- Review placement of security cameras and review monitoring practices
- Are alarm systems working and have they been tested? This should include main campus buildings as well as maintenance and storage facilities.
- Are keys to campus and administration buildings adequately controlled?
- Are alarm pass codes changed when an employee leaves the school district?
- Make sure pass codes are not shared.
- Is exterior lighting working and is illumination adequate?
- Is interior lighting (night lighting) working and is illumination adequate?
- If security cameras are used, coverage should include main doors and building exteriors, as well as interior locations.
- Make sure recording equipment is in working order and that a reasonable archive is maintained.
- If cameras are not live monitored, make sure that a periodic or spot review of critical areas takes place.
- Encourage students and staff to report suspicious activity quickly, so that video archives can be reviewed for evidence.
Module 4: Review access control procedures and heighten employee awareness
- Are doors that should remain locked from the outside during the day kept locked, and are these doors checked periodically to make sure they are secure? Train all employees to check these doors but consider assigning someone to check them as well.
- Are staff members trained to approach and to “assist” strangers of any age who are observed in and on school property? Report those who have difficulty explaining their presence.
- Are students trained to report suspicious persons or persons who may not be authorized on campus?
- Has a visitor log and ID badge system been implemented?
Module 5: Train everyone to recognize and report suspicious activities on campus.
- Are persons taking pictures or filming campus activities questioned about their authorization to do so?
- Be alert for suspicious vehicles that seem to have no apparent purpose for being on campus, or, that come, go, and then reappear again.
- Are specific individuals assigned to inspect the outside of campus buildings throughout the day, and to report unattended packages or vehicles near building perimeters?
- Have you developed a plan to handle reports of suspicious activity?
- Is everyone trained to report unattended or otherwise suspicious packages found inside campus buildings? Is this specific issue placed on routine checklists for maintenance and janitorial personnel?
- Do personnel know what to do if a suspicious package is found?
- Have you considered a policy that requires staff and students to visibly identify backpacks, book bags, briefcases and gym bags with luggage style ID tags?
- Everyone including students, janitorial, teachers, volunteers, & Student Resource Officers
Module 6: Implement a “tip-line” program that allows students, teachers, parents, staff, and other members of the school community to report issues anonymously, if they choose.
- Do you have a zero tolerance for verbal threats of any kind?
- Do all members of the school community know that any threat, or information about a potential threat, must be reported? And, do they understand that there is no such thing as a threat intended as a joke?
- Do students and staff know that they are responsible for informing the building principal about any information or knowledge of a possible or actual terrorist threat or act?
- Have you communicated a hard stand on hoaxes intended to mimic terrorist acts?
- Do students know that these hoaxes are crimes in themselves?
- Student Services
- PTA / PTO
- Resource Officers
Module 7: Work closely with local law enforcement, health officials, and first responders
- Have you made local law enforcement a partner in your district’s plans?
- Are parking regulations, particularly fire zone regulations, strictly enforced?
- Does local law enforcement have copies of building blueprints, to include ventilation system, and electrical plans?
- Has local law enforcement been given the opportunity to conduct exercises on school property and on busses?
- Have you determined contact protocol with local health officials if bio-terrorism is suspected?
- Clinical Staff
- Crisis Management Team
- Local Law Enforcement
- First Responders
- Local Health Officials
Module 8: Train staff on identifying and handling suspicious packages and letters.
- Have you download and posted the FBI advisory (poster) regarding suspicious packages from http://www.fbi.gov/?
- Or, the US Postal Inspection Service poster on identifying suspicious packages from http://www.usps.gov/?
- Have you considered publicizing the availability of this information to others in the school community for personal use?
- Have you ordered ATF forms: P 3320.5; P 7550.2; and 1613.1, regarding bomb threat planning?
- Mail Room
Remember, terrorists place their intended targets under surveillance prior to attack. They will study various potential targets as part of the target selection process in order to identify those with fatal weaknesses. While vigilance alone will not prevent a terrorist attack on a U.S. school, it may prevent your school from being selected for attack. Terrorists will likely select the softest amongst all of the targets considered. These may be rural schools serviced primarily by county sheriff departments or state police agencies. In other words, in places where the closest swat team or other first responders may not be just around the corner.
If you haven’t considered the possibility of a terrorist attack on a school in your district, or if your plans up to now have been solely reactive in nature, now is the time to act. Awareness is inexpensive and one of the most effective tools we have in the war on terror. However, we have to overcome the “it won’t happen here” thinking that paralyzes many Americans with an apparent reluctance to think or act. Moreover, don’t expect that the Fed, or for that matter your state will step in with a reasonable and proactive program to render your school or district a less soft target. All such efforts must come from within and must come now!